Home / September Popular Recipes

Our Most Popular Recipes for September

As summer fades and autumn begins, it’s the perfect time to indulge in comforting, seasonal recipes. These recipes round out our September favorites with a mix of international flavors, comforting classics, and fun seasonal treats. From indulgent pasta dishes to cozy bakes, we hope these dishes inspire your cooking adventures this fall. Here are the top recipes our readers have been loving this month. Happy cooking!

1
apple crumble served on a plate with lemon curd
Easy Apple Crumble (Mary Berry)
As autumn arrives, it’s perfect for those seeking a warm, homely apple crumble. Mary Berry's simple yet delicious recipe is one of the most sought-after throughout the year. The spike in interest reflects trust in her timeless approach, combining tart apples, buttery crumble, and tasty twists like oats or blackberries for the ultimate fall treat.
More Apple Crisps and Crumbles:
Mary Berry Crumble Tart (Blackberry and Apple Filling)
Mary Berry Blackberry and Apple Crumble
Foolproof Apple and Blackberry Crumble with Oats
Pioneer Woman's Apple Cobbler
Apple Crumble →
2
Buffalo wild wings street tacos
Street Tacos (BWW Copycat)
These Buffalo Wild Wings-inspired street tacos bring a deliciously tangy kick with tender, flavorful meat and toppings wrapped in soft tortillas. Perfect for game day or a quick dinner!
Street Tacos →
3
Mary Berry Rock Cakes with raisins
British Teatime Rock Cakes
Rock Cakes are an old teatime favorite, somewhat similar to scones but typically enjoyed on their own, without being split and topped with jam, butter, or cream. Best savored with a cup of tea, these delightful cakes feature dried fruit and currants scattered throughout, with a crunchy exterior and a soft, tender center. The natural sweetness of the dried fruit and currants stands out, and the recipe doesn’t require any additional spice.
Rock Cakes →
4
Cudighi sandwich with onions, marinara sauce, pickles and melted mozzarella cheese
Cudighi Sandwich
The Cudighi is a beloved sandwich native to Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, particularly in Marquette County. It’s especially popular among both locals and travelers who discover this regional specialty and enjoy making their own homemade versions, often customizing the spice blend to their liking. The sausage is a spiced Italian Cotechino-like patty served on a hard roll, usually topped with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese. Variations often include grilled onions and peppers. Though its origins trace back to Northern Italy, the Cudighi has evolved into a unique staple distinct to the Upper Peninsula.
Cudighi →
5
pioneer woman banana pecans bread
Banana Walnut Cake by Pioneer Woman
This Banana walnut cake makes a great upgrade to a classic banana bread – a perfect after school treat!. What I love most about this cake, and perhaps you would too, is that it combines ripe sweet bananas with crunchy walnuts without any frosting that hinders the aroma of ginger, cinnamon and nutmeg. And if you miss frosting, I suggest the cinnamon frosting in this other banana bread recipe. Otherwise, while the cake is still warm you can try pouring some brandy sauce used in my brandied banana fritters recipe.
Banana Walnut Cake →
6
bojangles breaded fried chicken tenders with a sauce on the side
Buttermilk Chicken Tenders (Bojangles Copycat)
Bojangles Chicken Tenders are made from tender cuts of chicken breast that are marinated in a special blend of spices, buttermilk, and other seasonings.
Buttermilk Chicken Tenders →
7
banana pudding with vanilla wafers and caramelised banana
Banana Pudding (Pioneer Woman)
Creamy layers of banana and vanilla pudding, topped with whipped cream and wafers, make this Pioneer Woman recipe a must-try dessert.
Banana Pudding →
8
chicken yock noodles
Chicken Yock Noodles
A savory noodle dish popular in the Southeast, Chicken Yock Noodles combines tender chicken with thick, flavorful noodles. A quick, comforting weeknight dinner!
Chicken Yock Noodles →
9
Coronation Chicken Sandwich
Coronation Chicken with Apricot Jam and Fresh Grapes
A perfect sandwich Filling and salad – this coronation chicken is quick and impressive! This retro favorite is perfect for sandwich fillings or salads. The apricot jam adds a touch of sweetness, balanced by fresh grapes and curry flavors.
Coronation Chicken →
10
Thomas English Muffins
Thomas English Muffins (Copycat)
Fluffy, homemade English muffins that toast perfectly with a crunchy exterior – ideal for breakfast or brunch.
English Muffins →
11
spaghetti carbonara with peas and ham
Garlicky Pasta Carbonara with Parmesan (Cheesecake Factory Copycat)
This rich and creamy carbonara is inspired by the Cheesecake Factory’s version, featuring a garlic Parmesan sauce that coats every strand of pasta. Perfect for a comforting dinner at home.
CF Pasta Carbonara →
12
strawberry bubble tea
Strawberry Boba Pearls & Boba Tea
Learn how to make chewy strawberry boba pearls and refreshing strawberry bubble tea from scratch. A fun and sweet treat for bubble tea lovers!
Strawberry Bubble Tea →
13
korean chicken gizzards
Korean Chicken Gizzards
A popular Korean street food, these tender chicken gizzards are stir-fried with garlic and spices for a deliciously savory dish that pairs well with rice or as a bar snack.
Korean Dakdungjip →
14
Ina garten corn salad with corn kernels, red onion thinly sliced into rings and basil leaves to garnish
Summer BBQ Corn Salad (Ina Garten)
This fresh and vibrant corn salad by Ina Garten combines sweet corn, red onions, and basil, all tossed in a tangy dressing. It’s a perfect side dish for barbecues or picnics.
BBQ Corn Salad →
15
ina garten's chicken piccata served with lemon slices the lemon wine sauce, crushed parsley and a glass of white wine
Chicken Piccata in Lemon Wine Sauce (Ina Garten)
Juicy chicken breasts in a zesty lemon-white wine sauce, this Chicken Piccata by Ina Garten is a simple yet elegant dish that’s perfect for a quick weeknight dinner.
Chicken Piccata →
16
quorn mince chilli
Quorn Chili con Carne
This easy vegetarian chili is made with Quorn mince, beans, and rich tomato sauce, spiced to perfection for a hearty, meat-free meal.
Quorn Chili →
17
Crispy Honey Chicken (PF Change Copycat)
Crispy fried chicken coated in a sticky, sweet honey glaze – this copycat recipe brings the flavors of PF Chang’s right to your kitchen.
Crispy Honey Chicken →
18
pumpkin spiced muffins
Pumpkin Spice Muffins (Tim Hortons Copycat)
Fall is here, and so is the pumpkin spice craze! These moist muffins are loaded with pumpkin flavor and a hint of spice, just like the ones at Tim Hortons.
Pumpkin Spice Muffins →
19
Creamy Tuna Pasta Bake
Creamy Tuna Pasta Bake
A creamy, cheesy tuna pasta bake with a golden breadcrumb topping. This comforting dish is a favorite for busy weeknights and family dinners.
Tuna Pasta Bake →
20
binangkal filipino sesame balls
Filipino Fried Sesame Balls (Binangkal)
Binangkal is a popular Filipino bread snack coated in sesame seeds. Crunchy on the outside and soft inside, these deep-fried treats are perfect for enjoying with coffee or tea.
Binangkal Sesame Balls →
Scroll to Top